Russia says there's no legal Ukrainian state

philebersole

Jun 27

The Russian Foreign Ministry recently stated that Russia does not recognize the legal existence of the Ukrainian state. That's an extreme statement.

During World War Two, the USA and UK recognized the German, Italian and Japanese governments and accepted terms of surrender from them.

But maybe I exaggerate the statement's significance. Russia already had announced it is no longer open to negotiation with Ukraine, as it was at the outset of the war. It does not ask Ukraine to accept terms of surrender, but rather intends to "demilitarize" and "denazify" Ukraine by force.

Here's what independent journalist John Helmer had to say.

In brief statements issued late last week in Moscow – their significance missed in the western press — President Vladimir Putin ordered a reality check of Russia's war strategy. He then answered himself by declaring the war will be over when no Ukrainian army will be left on the battlefield, nor NATO weapons.

The Foreign Ministry answered by pointing out that Russia does not recognize there is a legal Ukrainian state because the reality is that the mutual recognition treaty between Russia and the Ukraine was cancelled by Presidents Petro Poroshenko and Vladimir Zelensky in 2018 and 2019.

"We can conclude," Putin said at the Security Council meeting on Thursday morning, "that they can certainly send in additional equipment, but the mobilisation reserve is not unlimited. And Ukraine's Western allies really seem determined to fight with Russia to the last Ukrainian. At the same time, we must proceed from the fact that the enemy's offensive potential has not been exhausted; they may have strategic reserves yet unused, and I ask you to keep this in mind when making fighting strategies. You need to proceed from reality."

Putin was following by a few hours the statement by the Foreign Ministry that Russia does not recognize the legal sovereignty of the regime in Kiev, and that following the cancellation of the treaty between the Ukraine and Russia in 2019, there will be no Ukrainian state left to sign an end-of-war agreement.

At her weekly briefing of reporters, the ministry spokesman Maria Zakharova, was asked "when will Russia initiate a legal procedure to terminate the bilateral treaty with Ukraine on its sovereignty?" Zakharova answered: "The procedure for terminating the bilateral treaty with Ukraine on its sovereignty is hampered by the absence of such a treaty. In Article 1 of the Treaty on the Principles of Relations between the RSFSR and the Ukrainian SSR of November 19, 1990, the two republics recognised each other as 'sovereign states.' The 1990 treaty was then replaced by the Treaty on Friendship, Cooperation, and Partnership between the Russian Federation and Ukraine of May 31, 1997 (Article 39), which was denounced by Ukraine and terminated on April 1, 2019."

No army, no state. But the war will continue because it is the one between the US and the NATO powers and Russia. That too will have an ending, but longer.